Tag Archives: Tracy Chapman

Tracy Chapman Wins $450K in Copyright Suit Against Nicki Minaj

Screen Shot 2021 01 11 at 9.17.50 AM

After a more than two-year-long battle over the song “Sorry” which was slated to be on her Queen LP, rap icon Nicki Minaj has offered up $450,000 to acoustic singer Tracy Chapman to settle a judgment for the track and Chapman accepted.

Chapman initially sued Minaj in 2018 over the recording, which uses parts of her 1988 song “Baby Can I Hold You,” but a judge ruled that Minaj didn’t violate any copyright infringement laws by recording the record, but Minaj’s team was obviously unwilling to take the issue of whether “Sorry”’s song leak did violate Chapman’s rights all the way to trial. 

“It would have cost us more to go to trial,” said Minaj of her ultimate decision to not take the case to trial. Minaj admittedly didn’t know she was using Chapman’s song, as she thought she was borrowing from Shelly Thunder’s reggae hit “Sorry”, which uses elements of Chapman’s song as well.

Chapman contends that all she wanted out of the end result was for the rapper to just leave her music alone. “I am glad to have this matter resolved and grateful for this legal outcome which affirms that artists’ rights are protected by law and should be respected by other artists. I was asked in this situation numerous times for permission to use my song; in each instance, politely and in a timely manner, I unequivocally said no. Apparently Ms. Minaj chose not to hear and used my composition despite my clear and express intentions. As a songwriter and an independent publisher, I have been known to be protective of my work. I have never authorized the use of my songs for samples or requested a sample. This lawsuit was a last resort—pursued in an effort to defend myself and my work and to seek protection for the creative enterprise and expression of songwriters and independent publishers like myself,” she said.

The post Tracy Chapman Wins $450K in Copyright Suit Against Nicki Minaj appeared first on The Source.

Click Here to Discuss in the Forums

Spread the love
             
 
   

Nicki Minaj Loses $450K Lawsuit To Singer Tracy Chapman

New York rapper Nicki Minaj has had a roller-coaster week. It ends with the bad news for Nicki that she’s lost a $450,000 judgement to Grammy-winning singer Tracy Chapman, who accused the hip-hop superstar of using her work without permission. Nicki Minaj Sued By Tracy Chapman On Nicki Minaj’s song “Sorry” (featuring Nas) — originally […]

The post Nicki Minaj Loses $450K Lawsuit To Singer Tracy Chapman appeared first on SOHH.com.

Click Here to Discuss in the Forums

Spread the love
             
 
   

Nicki Minaj Loses $450K Lawsuit To Singer Tracy Chapman

New York rapper Nicki Minaj has had a roller-coaster week. It ends with the bad news for Nicki that she’s lost a $450,000 judgement to Grammy-winning singer Tracy Chapman, who accused the hip-hop superstar of using her work without permission. Nicki Minaj Sued By Tracy Chapman On Nicki Minaj’s song “Sorry” (featuring Nas) — originally […]

The post Nicki Minaj Loses $450K Lawsuit To Singer Tracy Chapman appeared first on SOHH.com.

Click Here to Discuss in the Forums

Spread the love
             
 
   

Judge Rules In Favor Of Nicki Minaj In Tracy Chapman Copyright Case

Screen Shot 2020 09 17 at 9.31.02 AM

According to several confirmed reports, Nicki Minaj landed a victory in court when a judge ruled that Minaj did not commit copyright infringement against Tracy Chapman for her 2017 hit “Sorry”.

Variety reported that U.S. district Judge Virginia A. Phillips ruled that Nicki’s experimentation with Tracy Chapman’s song constitutes “fair use” and is not copyright infringement.

“Artists usually experiment with works before seeking licenses from rights holders and rights holders typically ask to see a proposed work before approving a license,” the judge wrote. “A ruling uprooting these common practices would limit creativity and stifle innovation within the music industry.”

Minaj’s 2017 song “Sorry” featuring Nas contained most of the lyrics and some of the melody came from Chapman’s “Baby Can I Hold You,” which Minaj believed came from Shelly Thunder’s rendition of “Sorry”.

The ruling is significant for the music industry as it protects the practice of developing a new song based on existing material, and then seeking a license from the original artist prior to release. 

The post Judge Rules In Favor Of Nicki Minaj In Tracy Chapman Copyright Case appeared first on The Source.

Click Here to Discuss in the Forums

Spread the love
             
 
   

Nicki Minaj Gets Small Victory In Tracy Chapman Sample Battle

Nicki Minaj in Oslo.

Source: PYMCA / Getty

Nicki Minaj is still embroiled in the legal tussle with singer and songwriter Tracy Chapman, but her side can claim a small victory in the matter. The Queens rapper will not have to hand over private conversations between her and Funkmaster Flex to Chapman, who has accused Minaj of sampling her music without permission.


The Blast
reports:

In her [Chapman] motion, she claimed to learn new information during Minaj’s recent deposition. The court documents read, “Maraj’s deposition testimony made clear that she failed to produce many requested documents, including, but not limited to, (i) discoverable and responsive documents and correspondence maintained by her former manager, Gerald “Gee” Roberson (“Roberson”); and (ii) text messages with and a draft declaration sent to third-party Aston George Taylor, Jr. p/k/a Funkmaster Flex (“Taylor”).”

She added, “This is especially troubling and problematic given that Maraj’s correspondence with Taylor is crucial to determining whether Maraj violated Chapman’s copyright by distributing the Infringing Work to Taylor – a key element that goes directly to Chapman’s infringement claim, and the willfulness of Maraj’s wrongdoing.”

The judge decided Minaj does not have to turn over the messages at this point. The order read, “The Court also finds that Plaintiff has not shown a substantial need for the draft declarations. If a party may access information from other sources, substantial need is not shown.”

Chapman says her song “Baby Can I Hold You” was sampled for the song “Sorry,” an unreleased track that was set to appear on the Queen album.

Photo: Getty

Source: HipHopWired.com

Click Here to Discuss in the Forums

Spread the love
             
 
   

Funkmaster Flex Roped Into Tracy Chapman & Nicki Minaj Sampling Case

2018 MTV Europe Music Awards

Source: Dutch Press Photo/WENN.com / WENN

The ongoing sampling and copyright infringement case between singer Tracy Chapman and Nicki Minaj has an added development that could drag out the matter even longer. In recent court documents that were introduced, Chapman has named Funkmaster Flex in the matter after he played a shelved record featuring the singer’s music.


BOSSIP
exclusively reports that Chapman filed documents last week urging the courts to demand that Flex hand over any text correspondence he had with Minaj in order to support her case.

Last year, Chapman filed suit against Minaj, born Onika Maraj, for sampling her song “Baby Can I Hold You” for the “Sorry” track which featured Nas. The song was positioned to appear on Minaj’s Queen album but didn’t make the final cut as Chapman didn’t clear the go-ahead to use the sample.

Chapman’s side believes they have the right to request the correspondence between the pair as it will illustrate that Minaj handed out Chapman’s work without her permission. Further, Flex played the song during an appearance on Hot 97 ahead of the album’s release.

The judge is still waiting to rule on the request.

Photo: WENN

Source: HipHopWired.com

Click Here to Discuss in the Forums

Spread the love
             
 
   

Nicki Minaj & Tracy Chapman Fail To Reach Settlement, Copyright Lawsuit Forges On

Nicki Minaj

Source: Bernard Smalls / @PhotosByBeanz

It looks like fans won’t be streaming “Sorry” anytime soon.

According to The Blast, Nicki Minaj and Tracy Chapman have failed to reach an agreement during court-ordered mediation in the copyright infringement case. Chapman is accusing Minaj of unlawfully sampling her song “Baby Can I Hold You” for the track “Sorry,” but Minaj reportedly confirmed in court documents that the song never made it to her album because Chapman didn’t approve the sample.

Chapman and her attorneys, however, accuse Minaj of leaking the record to Funkmaster Flex who debuted the song on his show, which Minaj denies.

The publication reports that documents from the attempted mediation note that on October 2 the parties tried to privately hash out their issues; citing “the mediation was unsuccessful, and no settlement was reached. The settlement is not imminent,” after the “Fendi” rapper denied committing copyright infringement, and reportedly claimed fair use as her defense. Minaj also allegedly argued that Chapman doesn’t own the copyright herself, and is asking for the lawsuit to be dismissed.

It seems that lawsuits, lackluster sales, and Twitter jabs have gotten to the Queen Radio host, which is what many fans speculate led to her abrupt retirement announcement.

As previously reported, Nicki Minaj recently announced her retirement from Rap to “focus on building her family” back in August before recanting the decision one week later in early September. Nicki did give insight into the decision while responding to a fan saying:

“I’m still right here. Still madly in love with you guys & you know that. In hindsight, this should’ve been a Queen Radio discussion & it will be. I promise u guys will be happy. No guests, just us talking about everything. The tweet was abrupt & insensitive, I apologize babe.” 

The copyright lawsuit is slated to go to forward to court.

Source: HipHopWired.com

Click Here to Discuss in the Forums

Spread the love
             
 
   

Nicki Minaj Says She Doesn’t Owe Tracy Chapman In Sample Lawsuit

Church On Sundays Hosted By Nicki Minaj And Phil The Mayor And DJ Clues Birthday Party

Source: Johnny Nunez / Getty

Nicki Minaj found herself in the crosshairs of singer and songwriter Tracy Chapman after an unreleased track was leaked to the public. Minaj has fired back at Chapman, saying that while she did use the sample, the song was never sold and thus she doesn’t have to pay up.

The Blast reports:

According to court documents obtained by The Blast, Minaj is denying all allegations of wrongdoing in the case brought by Chapman claiming Nicki sampled her song “Baby Can I Hold You” on a track with Nas titled “Sorry.”

Minaj admits her team made several requests to Chapman to use her music and says those requests were denied. She also says she did record the song before getting permission.

In the court docs, Minaj says she did want to put “Sorry” on her album “Queen” but left it off due to not having clearance.

The outlet adds that Funkmaster Flex leaked the song to the public thus landing it on Chapman’s radar. The singer is seeking damages and an injunction against Minaj from using any of her original music.

Photo: Getty

Spread the love
             
 
   

Tracy Chapman Comes After Nicki Minaj’s Pockets Over Nas Song

New York rapper Nicki Minaj is getting some unwanted attention from a certified music veteran. Reports claim singer Tracy Chapman is taking legal action against Onika over her “Sorry” song.

According to reports, Chapman has targeted Nicki for not getting permission to sample her “Baby Can I Hold You” anthem for her Nas-featured record.

Chapman says in June 2018, Minaj and her reps made multiple requests to license “Baby Can I Hold You” and all requests were rejected. So imagine Tracy’s surprise when “Sorry” came out in August 2018 … it was supposed to be featured on Nicki’s album, “Queen.” Tracy says her song comprises half of the lyrics and vocal melody of “Sorry.” (TMZ)

Despite pulling the song from her Queen album, Nicki’s unapproved version still went viral.

According to the suit, Funkmaster Flex played “Sorry” on Hot 97 and lots of Internet users picked up the song and sent it around. It was also played on “The Breakfast Club” with Charlamagne Tha God. The day the track was played, Nicki tweeted, “Sis said no,” which, according to the lawsuit, refers to Chapman’s denial to her request to use “Baby Can I Hold You.” (TMZ)

In August, speculation emerged about Nicki and Nas’ record existing.

A few hours prior, Nicki’s former rival Funk Flex announced he would premiere the Nas collabo.

In early January, a report emerged about Nicki and Nas quietly splitting last month.

There were recent reports Nicki was pregnant, but we’re told there’s no truth to that. Both superstars will be getting back to strictly biz, we’re told — Nas focusing on his record label and his chicken and waffles joint, Sweet Chick. We’re told they respect each other, and there won’t be any trash talking — but, on the other hand, we’re also told they won’t be hanging out as friends either. (TMZ)

The post Tracy Chapman Comes After Nicki Minaj’s Pockets Over Nas Song appeared first on SOHH.com.

Spread the love
             
 
   

Nicki Minaj Sued by Tracy Chapman for Unauthorized Use of a Single

The Barbz won’t like this news but Nicki Minaj is being sued by Tracy Chapman. TMZ reports that Chapman believes the Queen creator stole her song “Baby Can I Hold You” for her Nas-featured single “Sorry.”

Chapman states Minaj attempted to establish a license for her song but they were rejected, the rapper would continue to release the song anyway in August. The song was supposed to be featured on the Queen album but made it to New York Hip-Hop stations.

“Sorry” was released on August 11, 2018. At the time of her album release, Minaj shared regret with Nas on Instagram that no one would be able to hear the single.

The lawsuit states that Nicki Minaj tweeted “Sis said no” when the song made it to the airwaves and her team worked to make sure there were no traces of the song online. The lawsuit is pursuing monetary damages from its use and wanting to stop the release of the song in the future.

Hear the original song from Tracy Chapman below.

The post Nicki Minaj Sued by Tracy Chapman for Unauthorized Use of a Single appeared first on The Source.

Spread the love